Published in Cataract

Mapping the Premium IOL Patient Journey: From Evaluation to Long-Term Satisfaction

This is editorially independent content supported by advertising from Bausch + Lomb
15 min read

Join Drs. McCabe and Donnenfeld as they discuss how to connect evaluation, patient education, surgery, and follow-up into a cohesive cataract surgery journey.

Mapping the Premium IOL Patient Journey: From Evaluation to Long-Term Satisfaction
Few decisions in medicine have the permanence of selecting an intraocular lens (IOL). Unlike a prescription that can be rewritten or a treatment plan that can be revised at the next visit, the IOL placed during cataract surgery will define how a patient perceives the world—every morning, every drive, every face across the dinner table—for the rest of their life.
This significant responsibility is what makes premium IOL surgery incredibly rewarding when successful and discouraging when it isn't. However, for many surgeons, the challenge isn’t the surgery itself; it’s everything surrounding it: the ocular health evaluation, discussing options with patients without overwhelming them, confidently making recommendations while respecting patient autonomy, and managing expectations to ensure that post-operative satisfaction matches the precision of the procedure.
This practical framework maps the premium IOL patient journey from first evaluation through post-operative follow-up, turning clinical excellence into patient outcomes that genuinely change lives.

Looking beyond the cataract at pre-op exams

The pre-operative evaluation should be a whole-eye approach that thoroughly evaluates ocular health. This demonstrates the investment in a premium experience before the lens conversation even starts.
Cataract surgery can temporarily or permanently impair the ocular surface, and the ability to restore or develop dysfunction depends on the ocular surface's capacity to counteract surgical stress. A healthy surface adapts well, promoting recovery, whereas undiagnosed pre-operative dry eye disease (DED) impairs this ability, increasing the risk of post-operative DED and causing variability in corneal measurements and IOL calculations, which can affect outcomes, especially with premium IOLs.1
A survey of advanced-technology IOL experts and non-expert US surgeons revealed that about two-thirds considered pre-surgical ocular surface optimization extremely or very important. However, around 30% rated it as only moderately or slightly important.2 Given that about 80% of patients undergoing cataract surgery have preexisting ocular surface disease, which can affect pre-surgical measurements and post-operative outcomes, ocular surface optimization is crucial.2
Post-operative DED can occur even in patients without prior dry eye disease. Studies have shown that new symptoms and post-operative DED can be found in patients post-phacoemulsification.1 Several pre-operative factors predict post-operative DED, including reduced TBUT, increased corneal fluorescein staining (CFS), conjunctivochalasis, and higher tear osmolarity.1
Surgeons should adopt a structured, individualized approach to enhance surgical success. Use risk stratification tools to determine the need for targeted diagnostics and include objective ocular surface assessments in the pre-operative evaluation. Optimize the ocular surface 3 to 6 weeks before surgery to improve measurement precision, post-operative comfort, visual outcomes, and patient satisfaction.1

Identifying retinal disease in cataract patients

A thorough evaluation of the posterior segment is crucial alongside assessment of the ocular surface in cataract patients, as many may have coexisting macular diseases. Routine fundus examination is a standard part of pre-operative cataract assessment, but subtle macular pathologies can be overlooked due to media opacity or poor pupil dilation.
These overlooked conditions can lead to incorrect treatment decisions and unrealistic expectations for post-operative outcomes, potentially causing patient dissatisfaction, especially in those with premium lenses.3 In a prospective survey study on knowledge gaps in cataract surgery, 85.7% of advanced-technology IOL experts considered tomography essential, compared with 28.4% of US cataract surgeons.2
Using tools such as spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) can provide a detailed cross-sectional view of the macula, enhancing pre-operative diagnostics even in challenging conditions.3 Additionally, OCT can offer a more objective assessment of visual prognosis and guide surgical planning.2

Considering astigmatism in surgical planning

Besides ocular health, considering posterior corneal astigmatism (PCA) is crucial in toric IOL power calculation, as it enhances accuracy by preventing overcorrection in eyes with with-the-rule corneal astigmatism and undercorrection in those with against-the-rule. Using actual posterior corneal measurements, such as with a biometer,4 is of great importance, rather than relying on statistical estimates for against-the-rule astigmatism.
Surgeons should practice zero tolerance for cylinder, as residual astigmatism (>0.5D) undermines premium outcomes. Low levels of residual astigmatism can degrade visual acuity and patient satisfaction. Corneal astigmatism of 0.50D or greater should be included in surgical planning.5
In Rocha et al. (2026), the advanced-technology IOL expert cohort had a lower threshold for treating astigmatism with toric IOLs compared to the US cataract surgeon cohort.2 They employed a wider range of strategies, including toric IOLs, limbal relaxing incisions, on-axis incisions, and astigmatic keratotomy.
For patients with irregular astigmatism, the expert cohort preferred monovision with a partial-depth of field (DOFi) extended IOL for presbyopia correction, aligning with published case reports.
Donnenfeld Quote 1

The patient conversation: Listen, evaluate, choose

In cataract surgery planning, shared decision-making (SDM) between surgeon and patient is of greatest importance. When structured well, it increases patient satisfaction with the decision itself—not just the clinical outcome. The key is to provide enough information to support an informed choice without entirely offloading the cognitive burden onto the patient.
The choice of IOL must consider both the patient’s objective (ocular and systemic conditions) and their subjective (lifestyle) needs. While comprehensive pre-operative assessments help understand patients’ lifestyles and expectations, mismatches between objective conditions and subjective needs can occur, hindering optimal IOL selection.
The shift towards patient-centered (SDM) care involves healthcare professionals discussing options with patients, weighing the pros and cons while considering their values.6
Dr. Donnenfeld states that there are three parts to the patient conversation:
  1. Listen: Patients arrive with assumptions, anxieties, and visual priorities that may not align with the surgeon's expectations. Some want freedom from reading glasses above all else; others prioritize night driving. Letting the patient articulate their goals first prevents the surgeon from defaulting to a recommendation that fits the clinical picture but misses the patient's lived experience.
  2. Evaluate: Assess overall ocular health to determine which IOL options are realistic.
  3. Choose: After listening and evaluating, provide a strong and confident recommendation grounded in what is best for that patient.
Donnenfeld Quote 2
One thing surgeons should take into account is projecting confidence. Patients can sense indecision, and indecision erodes trust. The “paradox of choice” suggests that having too many options can lead to decision paralysis rather than greater satisfaction. While more choices are generally seen as positive and linked to personal freedom, they can overwhelm individuals, especially in medical decision-making.
Research shows that providing fewer options—rather than a stack of brochures—leads to better decisions and improved well-being. It’s recommended to simplify discussions to two or three clear paths, starting with a personalized recommendation before presenting alternatives.7

Setting expectations before cataract surgery

High-quality chair time correlates with long-term satisfaction. Some physicians feel that their busy schedules limit their ability to guide patients, hindering SDM. The complexity of IOLs can also make it difficult for cataract patients to understand their options.
This can be addressed by creating a multidisciplinary team comprising health educators and experienced nurses to educate patients on decision-making, thereby reducing the time burden on physicians and facilitating SDM.6
In a study by Ison et al. (2021), only 39% of patients reported being willing to use reading glasses in exchange for fewer visual phenomena.8 This is a notable change compared to an earlier study by Mester et al. (2014), which found that about 80% of patients were willing to use reading glasses after receiving multifocal IOLs.9
This trend indicates that patients are developing higher expectations, particularly concerning independence from glasses. In fact, 90% of patients in Ison's study expressed willingness to tolerate increased halo effects or other visual disturbances in exchange for a greater likelihood of being spectacle-free.8
This evidence underscores the importance of high-quality "chair time," in which surgeons clearly communicate expectations. For patients choosing monofocal lenses, it's crucial to explain that everything within arm's length—like phones and menus—will appear blurry without correction. Many patients mistakenly believe they'll be completely free of glasses, which can lead to dissatisfaction post-surgery, even with a technically perfect outcome.
For premium IOL candidates, expectation management is more nuanced. Multifocal IOLS achieve higher rates of spectacle independence than monofocals but are also associated with increased dysphotopsia (glare, halos) and reduced contrast sensitivity—trade-offs that must be discussed candidly.10
Matching a patient to a lens platform is not a conversation about "the best lens" but about the best balance between that patient's health profile, visual expectations, lifestyle demands, and tolerance for optical compromise.
McCabe Quote 1

Building confidence with premium IOLs

As young surgeons gain experience, they typically follow a natural progression in their proficiency with cataract surgery: starting with comfort in using monofocal lenses and gradually expanding into premium lens options as they acquire hands-on experience and build confidence.
However, this progression does not occur automatically; it can be either accelerated or hindered by the presence or absence of mentorship. Mentors can be found during residency, fellowship, or by actively seeking out pioneering figures in the field.
A scoping review conducted by Bourke, Conway, and Abdallah (2025) identified five key areas in which surgical mentorship has the greatest impact:11
  1. Preventing burnout
  2. Enhancing surgical skills and performance
  3. Advancing career progression
  4. Promoting diversity
  5. Maintaining work-life balance
Mentees who receive structured mentorship tend to demonstrate better surgical outcomes and greater confidence in the operating room. Surveys of trainees have indicated that developing clinical skills and clinical confidence are among the top priorities for mentoring, highlighting that confidence with premium IOLs is an acquired skill rather than an inherent trait.
Great mentors exemplify careful preparation, utilize structured checklists, review calculations meticulously, and adhere to diagnostic examination protocols.

The post-operative journey

Cataract evaluation is a continuous, collaborative process rather than a one-time event. After surgery, it’s essential to reassess whether the initial goals have been achieved. Post-operative adjustments, such as enhancement procedures for residual refractive error or targeted dry eye treatments, are standard steps to optimize outcomes and should not be seen as signs of failure.
Dry eye management remains crucial after surgery. Typically, tear film disruption is transient and resolves spontaneously within about 3 months, but it can significantly affect early patient satisfaction and visual quality.12 Proactive measures such as artificial tears, anti-inflammatory agents, and punctal occlusion, when needed, are vital components of the post-operative care routine.12,13
McCabe Quote 2
Managing patient expectations is critical, as overly high or unrealistic beliefs can undermine satisfaction more than the surgical result itself. Controlling patient expectations often plays a more significant role in achieving satisfaction than the actual outcome. Therefore, the post-operative period also offers the best opportunity for clinicians to make a meaningful impact with patient education.
When expectations are properly set before surgery, patients are more likely to perceive early symptoms such as mild blur, dryness, or light sensitivity as normal and temporary. Conversely, patients with unaddressed unrealistic expectations tend to contact the office for reassurance, question their outcomes, and may report dissatisfaction, even if their visual acuity is excellent.
IOL journey flowchart

Conclusion

The premium IOL patient journey is a continuous process from evaluation to long-term follow-up. Both clinical accuracy and effective communication are essential at every stage.
The IOL Compass Summit emphasizes that cataract surgery aims to enhance the patient's overall quality of life, not just improve vision. Surgeons who prioritize this holistic approach ensure their patients leave not only seeing well but also feeling satisfied with their experience.
  1. Coco G, Messmer EM, Starr CE, et al. A Practical Approach for Optimizing Ocular Surface Status Before Cataract Surgery to Improve Visual Outcomes and Reduce the Risk of Postoperative Dry Eye. Ophthalmol Ther. 2025;14(11):2697-2733. doi:10.1007/s40123-025-01251-7
  2. Rocha KM, Feulner L, Tyson F, et al. Intraocular lens selection in US cataract surgery: A prospective survey informing an expert-derived clinical decision tool. Exp Rev Ophthalmol. 2026;21(5):487-497. doi:10.1080/17469899.2026.2706115
  3. Kowallick A, Fischer CV, Hoerauf H. Optical coherence tomography findings in patients prior to cataract surgery regarded as unremarkable with ophthalmoscopy. PLoS One. 2018;13(12):e0208980. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0208980
  4. Stewart S, Yeo TK, Moutari S, McNeely RN, Moore JE. Effect of Posterior Corneal Surgically Induced Astigmatism on Toric Intraocular Lens Power Calculations. Clin Ophthalmol. 2025;19:35-43. doi:10.2147/OPTH.S488571
  5. Schallhorn SC, Hettinger KA, Pelouskova M, et al. Effect of residual astigmatism on uncorrected visual acuity and patient satisfaction in pseudophakic patients. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2021;47(8):991-998. doi:10.1097/j.jcrs.0000000000000560
  6. Dai J, Hua Y, Chen Y, et al. Current Status of Shared Decision-Making in Intraocular Lens Selection for Cataract Surgery: A Cross-Sectional Study. Patient Prefer Adherence. 2024;18:1311-1321. doi:10.2147/PPA.S468452
  7. Baum N, Bauer BC, Powell E. The paradox of choice in Healthcare: Treating decision paralysis. Healthcare Administration Leadership & Management Journal. 2023;1(5):233-237. doi:10.55834/halmj.5000639616
  8. Ison M, Scott J, Apel J, Apel A. Patient Expectation, Satisfaction and Clinical Outcomes with a New Multifocal Intraocular Lens. Clin Ophthalmol. 2021;15:4131-4140. doi:10.2147/OPTH.S327424
  9. Mester U, Vaterrodt T, Goes F, et al. Impact of personality characteristics on patient satisfaction after multifocal intraocular lens implantation: results from the “Happy Patient Study”. J Refract Surg. 2014;30(10):674–678. doi:10.3928/1081597X-20140903-05
  10. Wang SY, Stem MS, Oren G, et al. Patient-centered and visual quality outcomes of premium cataract surgery: a systematic review. Eur J Ophthalmol. 2017;27(4):387-401. doi:10.5301/ejo.5000978
  11. Bourke L, Conway C, Abdalla ME. Mentorship in surgical training; a systematic scoping review to inform a mentorship framework for ophthalmology trainees. BMC Med Educ. 2025;25(1):373. doi:10.1186/s12909-025-06901-9
  12. Ta H, McCann P, Xiao M, et al. Dry eye post-cataract surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Ophthalmol. 2025;25(1):18. doi:10.1186/s12886-024-03841-8
  13. Spritz S, Ruiz-Lozano RE, Bibak-Bejandi Z, et al. Management of Dry Eye Disease Pre- and Post-Cataract Surgery: A Personalized Approach. J Pers Med. 2026;16(2):86. doi:10.3390/jpm16020086
Eric Donnenfeld, MD
About Eric Donnenfeld, MD

Eric Donnenfeld, MD is one of the ophthalmology industry's leading experts. With a career spanning over 20 years, he has helped to revolutionize the field. He is highly passionate about ophthalmology, his career, and helping his patients.

Eric Donnenfeld, MD
Cathleen McCabe, MD
About Cathleen McCabe, MD

Cathleen McCabe, MD, serves as Chief Medical Officer at Eye Health America™. She is one of the foremost eye surgeons today, specializing in bladeless laser cataract surgery at The Eye Associates in Sarasota, Florida. Dr. McCabe has performed over 50,000 cataract surgeries. She has a keen interest in advancing the field of ophthalmology and has participated in numerous clinical trials, including innovations in intraocular lenses, perioperative medications, medications and devices to treat glaucoma, dry eye treatments, and presbyopia correction.

Dr. McCabe continues to receive many prestigious and esteemed awards for her work in Ophthalmology, including being named a Castle Connolly Top Doctor – 2015 to 2021 for Ophthalmology. Castle Connolly also selected her for the first-ever Exceptional Women In Medicine Award for 2017 to 2020. She was named to the OSN Premier Surgeon 300 List, and the Premier Surgeon 250 List of Leading Innovators in Premium IOL Cataract Surgery.

She was also chosen a LASERVISION Top 100 LASIK Surgeon, elected President of CEDARS/ASPEN-2017, has received the American Academy Achievement and Secretariat Awards, is the President of the Outpatient Ophthalmic Surgery Society, the chair of the Refractive Surgery Clinical Committee for the American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery (ASCRS), serves on the governing board of ASCRS and serves on numerous editorial and subspecialty boards and committees.

Dr. McCabe was most recently honored for being on the Global Top 100 Power list for 2021 and 2022. She has leadership positions in mentoring and international educational organizations, including YoungMDConnect, Global Education and Research Society in Ophthalmology, and serves as an advisor to many ophthalmology industry partners.

She is passionate about giving back to her local community, profession, and globally, and participates in charitable giving and volunteer efforts both at home and abroad. She is a board member of several charitable foundations in ophthalmology, including One World Global Health/Sight for Life, OOSS Gives, and others.

Dr. McCabe received her medical degree from the Medical College of Wisconsin and received her residency training at the prestigious Bascom Palmer Eye Institute at the University of Miami’s School of Medicine. She continues to share her expertise by publishing articles and book chapters as well as lecturing at national and international ophthalmological seminars.

Cathleen McCabe, MD